Subcontractors

How to vet a subcontractor before they start on site

12 min read

The short answer

Before a subcontractor starts, verify them with HMRC for CIS so you know whether to deduct 20%, 30% or nothing, and check they are self-employed rather than an employee, using HMRC’s CEST tool if in doubt. Since 1 October 2026, if you engage an individual to do work you have contracted to provide, you must check their right to work in the UK before they start, or face a civil penalty of up to £60,000. Check that a subcontractor who employs anyone holds employers’ liability insurance of at least £5 million, and ask for the public liability cover your contract requires. CDM 2015 requires you to take reasonable steps to satisfy yourself they are competent, gas work must be done by a Gas Safe registered business, and CSCS cards are a site rule, not a legal requirement. Then get their RAMS and a written subcontract.

At a glance

CIS verification
Before the first payment
No need to re-verify
If on a CIS return in the current or last 2 tax years
CIS rates
20%, 30% or 0% (gross)
Right to work
Individual subcontractors, from 1 October 2026
Employers’ liability cover
At least £5 million (1998 Regulations, reg 3)
Public liability
Contractual, not a legal requirement
Competence duty
CDM 2015 reg 8(3)
CSCS card
Site rule, not law

What should you check before a subcontractor starts?

Some of these checks are legal duties that land on you, some are terms you set in the subcontract, and some are site rules. Knowing which is which tells you what you cannot skip.

CheckRequired byWhere to check
CIS registration and deduction rateLaw, before the first paymentHMRC’s CIS online service or CIS software
Self-employed, not an employeeLaw (tax and the CIS return declaration)HMRC’s CEST tool
Right to work in the UKLaw, for individual subcontractors from 1 October 2026A prescribed Home Office check
Employers’ liability insuranceLaw, if they employ anyoneTheir certificate
Public liability insuranceYour subcontractTheir certificate
Competence for the workCDM 2015; in England, Building Regulations Part 2AQualifications, references, past work
Gas Safe registrationLaw, for work on gas fittingsGas Safe Register
Competent person schemeThe route to self-certify notifiable workThe scheme’s register
CSCS cardsSite rules, not lawCSCS Smart Check
Company and VAT detailsGood practiceCompanies House; HMRC’s VAT number checker
RAMS for their packageTheir risk assessment is a legal dutyTheir document

Great Britain. Building Regulations Part 2A applies in England.

Is the business who it says it is?

For a limited company, Companies House shows the registered office, the date of incorporation, current and resigned directors, and insolvency information, free, with email alerts when the company changes its details. HMRC’s online checker confirms whether a UK VAT number is valid and gives the name and address it is registered to. Both should match the invoice you will be paying.

How do you verify a subcontractor for CIS?

Before you pay a new subcontractor, verify them with HMRC through the CIS online service or CIS software. HMRC tells you whether they are registered and which rate to use: 20% for a registered subcontractor, 30% for an unregistered one, or nothing if they hold gross payment status.

  • From a sole trader: their UTR and National Insurance number. Temporary numbers cannot be verified.
  • From a limited company: the company name, company UTR and registration number.
  • From a partnership: the nominated partner’s details, the trading name and the partnership UTR.

The details must match exactly what the subcontractor registered with. You need not verify again a subcontractor you have included on a CIS return in the current tax year or the last two. One you last paid three tax years ago is verified again, as if new. The deduction then goes on the labour element only: see how CIS deductions are calculated.

Free toolCIS deduction calculatorEnter the invoice, take out materials and VAT, and see the deduction at the rate HMRC gave you.

Is the subcontractor really self-employed?

CIS registration says nothing about employment status. HMRC’s guidance tells contractors to check whether they should employ the person instead, and every monthly CIS return carries a declaration that the subcontractors on it are not employees. A wrong declaration can bring a penalty of up to £3,000.

HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool asks about the contract, the worker’s responsibilities, who decides what work is done and when, where and how it is done, and how the worker is paid. HMRC stands by the result as long as the information you gave is accurate. Run it again when the arrangement changes: a subcontractor who started on a priced package and has been on day rate under your foreman for a year may give a different answer.

NoteTax status and insurance status are separate questions. HSE’s guide to employers’ liability insurance says someone self-employed for tax may still be your employee for insurance purposes, depending on how much control you have over the work.

Do you need to check a subcontractor’s right to work?

From 1 October 2026, often yes. Section 48 of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025, in force that day, extends the right to work rules from employees to workers and individual sub-contractors. An individual sub-contractor is an individual who contracts with you to provide work that you have contracted with a third party to provide. A sole trader you take on for the brickwork on your client’s extension fits that definition.

  • Individual subcontractors. Do a prescribed right to work check before they start: a manual check of original documents, the Home Office online check, or a check through a right to work digital verification service provider. A check done for any other purpose, such as a licence, does not count.
  • Subcontracting to a firm. Where you subcontract work you are contracted to provide, you can be treated as employing whoever does it, however far down the chain. The Home Office’s own example is a builder using subcontracted firms for foundations and bricklaying. Your defence is a written statement of terms in the subcontract, in place before work starts, requiring the firm to do right to work checks, not to subcontract further without your written consent, to allow audits, to accept suspension or termination if illegal working is found, and to cooperate with any Home Office investigation.
  • Not in scope. A self-employed tradesperson running their own business and contracting directly with their own customers. The Home Office’s example is a plumber fixing a householder’s tap.

A business found employing someone illegally without having done the prescribed checks faces a civil penalty of up to £60,000 for each illegal worker. The extended rules apply to engagements from 1 October 2026, with no general grace period.

What insurance must a subcontractor hold?

Employers’ liability insurance is compulsory under the Employers’ Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969 for any business that employs people in Great Britain, with limited exceptions such as an unincorporated family business employing only close relatives. Regulation 3 of the 1998 Regulations sets the minimum at £5 million for any one occurrence, costs included, from an authorised insurer. Gov.uk says an employer can be fined £2,500 for every day it is not properly insured, and £1,000 for not displaying the certificate or showing it to an inspector.

Public liability insurance is different. HSE describes it as generally voluntary: no law makes a subcontractor hold it. It covers claims from the public and other businesses, which on a building site means your client, the neighbour and the other trades, so your subcontract should require it, with the level of cover you need.

  • Get the certificate, not a verbal assurance, and check the insured name matches the business you are contracting with.
  • Check the policy covers the trade they are doing for you, and note the expiry date.
  • A sole trader with no employees needs no employers’ liability cover for themselves, but once they employ a labourer, it applies.

How do you check a subcontractor is competent?

Regulation 8 of the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 requires a contractor to have the skills, knowledge and experience, and if an organisation, the organisational capability, to do the work safely. Whoever appoints them must take reasonable steps to satisfy themselves that they do. Regulation 15(7) adds that a contractor must not put anyone on site without the skills, knowledge, training and experience for the tasks, or who is not in the process of obtaining them. In England, regulation 11E of the Building Regulations 2010, in force since 1 October 2023, requires the same reasonable steps before you let anyone carry out building work, measured against the competence requirement in regulation 11F, with a trainee allowed under supervision.

In practice, reasonable steps for most packages means asking for the trade qualifications, references from recent clients or main contractors, and addresses or photographs of similar work you can look at. For a larger package, ask how they will supervise their own people.

Gas and notifiable work

Under regulation 3 of the Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998, nobody may work on a gas fitting unless competent, and in homes and in workplaces such as shops and schools HSE says the work must be done by a Gas Safe registered engineer qualified for it. Regulation 3(2) puts a duty on you, too, if you control the work or have it done at a place you control. Check the business on the Gas Safe Register website and the engineer’s ID card, which shows the categories of work they are qualified for.

In England, a trade contractor who is a member of a government-authorised competent person scheme can self-certify certain building work, such as notifiable electrical work, instead of getting building regulations approval. If your subcontractor is going to self-certify, check their membership covers that type of work. If they are not a member, the work needs building control.

CSCS cards

CSCS says holding a card is not a legislative requirement: whether a card is needed to get on site is up to the principal contractor or client, though most principal contractors and major housebuilders require one. CSCS issues thirteen card types for different occupations and levels, and says cards should be checked with CSCS Smart Check, because a visual inspection will not catch a card that is fake, revoked or fraudulently obtained.

What should you ask for before they start work?

  1. 01A RAMS for their package. Employers and the self-employed both have a duty under regulation 3 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 to assess the risks of their work. Their RAMS shows it, and you check it fits your site: see what a RAMS must contain.
  2. 02A site induction, recorded, before they start.
  3. 03A written subcontract. Section 110 of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 requires every construction contract to have an adequate mechanism for working out what payments become due and when, and a final date for payment. A pay-when-paid clause is ineffective under section 113 unless the payer upstream is insolvent. See subcontractor agreements: what must be in writing.
  4. 04The right to work terms, in the subcontract with any firm, before work starts.
  5. 05Copies of everything above, with expiry dates, on your file for the job.

How often should you re-check a subcontractor?

Vetting is a snapshot, and most of what you checked has a date on it.

  • Insurance: at each renewal date. A certificate that expires mid-job is the commonest gap.
  • CSCS and other cards: at expiry, and with Smart Check rather than a glance at the gate.
  • Gas Safe and scheme membership: check the register again, and the engineer’s ID card, which shows whether their qualifications are in date.
  • CIS: verify again if you have not included them on a return in the current or last two tax years.
  • Employment status: run CEST again when the way they work for you changes.
  • Right to work: follow-up checks where their permission to work is time-limited, as the Home Office guide sets out.
  • Companies House: set an alert for each limited company you use.

How does Estimark help?

The subcontractor register holds each firm’s trade, approval status and date, performance rating and CIS position: UTR, the verification number and date HMRC gave you, and the tax treatment. Insurance policies and accreditations sit against the subcontractor with the provider, policy number, cover, excess, start, expiry and renewal dates, a verified flag and the certificate itself. Nothing chases a renewal automatically, but what is about to lapse is a report you can run.

Operatives’ CSCS and other cards go in training and qualifications with the card number, expiry date and certificate, and an alert before they lapse. Card details are entered by hand; Estimark does not check a card with CSCS. At the gate, QR site attendance can refuse or warn on a clock-on without a valid induction, an in-date CSCS card or acceptance of the current RAMS, set per job and off until you switch it on. The scan page needs no login, so a subcontractor’s operative can sign the RAMS there.

NoteEstimark does not verify subcontractors with HMRC, check right to work or decide employment status. It holds the results of the checks you make, with the dates that tell you when to make them again.

Sources

Questions

Frequently asked

Do I have to verify a subcontractor with HMRC every time I pay them?

No. You verify before the first payment. You need not verify again if you have included the subcontractor on a CIS return in the current tax year or the previous two. If you have not, verify them again as if they were new.

Is public liability insurance a legal requirement for subcontractors?

No. HSE describes public liability insurance as generally voluntary. Employers’ liability insurance is the compulsory one, at least £5 million, for any business with employees. Most main contractors make public liability a condition of the subcontract, and you set the level of cover.

Does a subcontractor need a CSCS card by law?

No. CSCS says holding a card is not a legislative requirement, and it is up to the principal contractor or client whether workers need one on site. Most principal contractors and major housebuilders do require one, and CSCS says cards should be checked with CSCS Smart Check.

Do I need to check a self-employed subcontractor’s right to work?

From 1 October 2026, yes if they are an individual you engage to do work you have contracted to provide to a client: do a prescribed right to work check before they start. If you subcontract to a firm, put the Home Office’s required right to work terms in the subcontract. A tradesperson contracting directly with their own customers is outside the rules.

How much employers’ liability insurance must a subcontractor have?

At least £5 million for any one occurrence, including costs, under regulation 3 of the Employers’ Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Regulations 1998, from an authorised insurer. It applies to any business that employs people, with limited exceptions.

Does Estimark verify subcontractors with HMRC?

No. Estimark holds the subcontractor’s UTR, the verification number and date you obtained from HMRC and the tax treatment, and applies that treatment to the deduction. The verification itself is done through HMRC’s CIS online service or your CIS software.

Build on a solid foundation.

Run the whole business without an implementation project and without legacy baggage. Every plan starts with 14 days free. No card needed.

Estimating · Jobs · Invoicing · CIS · H&S · Reactive maintenance