Running the business

Cash flow for small builders: why profitable jobs still run out of money

12 min read

The short answer

A profitable job can still run out of money because profit is earned as the work is done, while cash only arrives when the customer pays, and on a building job the costs go out first. Materials are bought before the stage they go into is paid for, labour is paid weekly, interim payments arrive weeks after each application, and retention holds back part of every payment until completion and beyond. A subcontractor paid under CIS also has 20% of the labour withheld as an advance payment of tax, and VAT can fall due on an invoice before the customer has paid it. The answer is a weekly cash flow forecast thirteen weeks ahead, stage payments that track your costs, and payment terms you chase to the date. Profit says whether the job paid; cash says whether the business gets through it.

At a glance

Right to stage payments
Unless the work is to last under 45 days (HGCRA s.109)
Pay when paid clauses
Ineffective unless a payer up the chain is insolvent (s.113)
Suspension for non-payment
At least 7 days’ notice (s.112)
VAT tax point, stage payments
Earlier of payment or VAT invoice
VAT on retention
Due when paid or invoiced
Cash Accounting Scheme
Join at £1.35 million or less
VAT return and payment
1 month and 7 days after the period
CIS deduction, registered subcontractor
20% of the labour

Why does a profitable job run out of cash?

Because profit and cash are counted at different moments. Profit is earned as the work goes in: the value of what is done, less what it cost. Cash moves when somebody pays. On a building job you pay first and get paid later, and every week in between has to be funded from somewhere. A cash flow forecast is the record of how big that gap gets and when.

  • Materials before the stage. You buy the blocks, the steel and the timber before the stage they go into is valued, and often before it starts.
  • Labour every week. Wages and labour-only subcontractors are paid weekly or fortnightly; your customer pays monthly, at stages, or at the end.
  • Payment periods. On commercial work the money for a month’s work arrives weeks after the application for it, on the final date for payment the contract sets.
  • Retention. A percentage of each interim payment is held back and comes back in parts, at completion and at the end of the defects period, on the contract’s terms. See retention and how to get it released.
  • CIS deductions. A subcontractor has 20% of the labour withheld, or 30% if not registered, and a sole trader gets any overpayment back only through the Self Assessment return.
  • VAT timing. VAT on an invoice can be due to HMRC before the customer has paid it.
  • Variations. Extra work done now and argued about later is cost with no income attached until it is agreed.

A job can show a profit every week and still need more cash than it will ever make.

What does a job’s cash look like against its profit?

An illustrative eight-week commercial subcontract worth £60,000, priced to cost £51,000 and make £9,000. Labour of £3,000 is paid every week. Materials of £18,000 arrive in three deliveries, in weeks 1, 3 and 5, on a trade account paid four weeks after each delivery. Plant hire of £8,000 is paid in two monthly instalments, and £1,000 of waste and skips is paid in week 8. Applications go in at the end of weeks 4 and 8 and are paid four weeks later, less 5% retention, and half the retention comes back in week 13. The subcontractor has gross payment status and the reverse charge applies, so neither CIS nor VAT moves any cash.

WeekPaid outReceivedCash positionProfit earned to date
1£3,000£0-£3,000£1,050
2£3,000£0-£6,000£2,100
3£3,000£0-£9,000£3,150
4£7,000£0-£16,000£4,200
5£11,000£0-£27,000£5,400
6£3,000£0-£30,000£6,600
7£9,000£0-£39,000£7,800
8£8,000£26,600-£20,400£9,000
9£4,000£0-£24,400£9,000
10£0£0-£24,400£9,000
11£0£0-£24,400£9,000
12£0£30,400£6,000£9,000
13£0£1,500£7,500£9,000

Illustrative figures for a worked example, not market rates. Profit earned is taken as 15% of the work done each week, for simplicity. The last £1,500 of retention is still to come.

The job makes £9,000 and is in profit every single week. At its lowest, in week 7, it has taken £39,000 out of the business, more than four times what it will make, and it does not pay for itself until week 12. The first application, for £28,000 of work less £1,400 retention, arrives in the same week as the last wage bill.

Now change the assumptions the way they usually change. Without gross payment status, 20% of the labour in each payment would be withheld. If the main contractor paid a week late, the low point would last a week longer. Run two jobs like this over the same weeks and the business needs nearly £80,000 of cash to earn £18,000 of profit.

How do you build a 13-week cash flow forecast?

Thirteen weeks is a quarter: long enough to see the next VAT payment and at least two monthly valuation cycles coming, and short enough to forecast by the week from dates you already know. Update it on the same day every week, in a spreadsheet if nothing else.

  1. 01Start from the bank, not the accounts. Today’s actual balance across every business account, less anything already sent but not yet cleared.
  2. 02List every receipt by the week you expect it. Each application or invoice outstanding, at the final date for payment or the due date on the invoice, moved later where you know the customer pays late. Add deposits and stage payments in the week their milestone should be reached, and retention in the week it is due back.
  3. 03List every payment by the week it leaves. Wages and labour-only subcontractors each week; supplier accounts on their due dates, not their delivery dates; plant hire; vehicle and finance payments; insurance; rent.
  4. 04Add the tax dates. The VAT return and payment one calendar month and seven days after each quarter ends. If you pay subcontractors, the CIS deductions you made, paid with PAYE by the 22nd of each month. Self Assessment or Corporation Tax on their own dates.
  5. 05Run the balance. Opening balance, plus receipts, less payments, week by week. Mark the lowest week and how low it goes.
  6. 06Decide now what the lowest week needs. While it is still weeks away: stagger materials orders, invoice every stage the day it is reached, ask for the deposit or stage payment the quote allows, talk to suppliers about terms, or arrange borrowing before you need it.
  7. 07Roll it forward every week. Drop the week just gone, add a new week 13, and compare what happened with what you forecast. The misses tell you which customers to forecast later next time.

NoteA forecast is only as good as its dates. The contract gives you a final date for payment; the customer’s habit may be a week or two later. Forecast on whichever is later.

Treat supplier credit as part of the plan. A trade account’s payment terms are money you are using until the due date, so order materials so that the account falls due after the stage payment or application they belong to, and pay to terms so the account stays open when the next job needs it.

How should deposits and stage payments work on domestic jobs?

On work for a homeowner there is no statutory payment scheme. The Construction Act does not apply to a contract with a residential occupier, so the payment terms are whatever the accepted quote says, and the quote becomes the cash flow document. There is no standard deposit or stage pattern to copy; set them from your own costs on the job.

  • Match the deposit to what you must buy before you start. Materials ordered for the job and long-lead items are the obvious cases.
  • Tie each stage payment to an event the customer can see. Foundations in, roof watertight, first fix complete. A payment due "in week four" invites an argument about progress; one due on a stage does not.
  • Put a stage payment before each big spend. If the kitchen is ordered at first fix, put a stage payment at first fix.
  • Invoice the day a stage is reached. Every day between reaching it and invoicing it is a day added to the wait.

Where you agreed the contract in the customer’s home, the cancellation rules affect when you can start and what you can keep; see can a customer cancel building work. Quoting the terms and chasing them are in getting paid faster.

What does the Construction Act give you on commercial work?

On a construction contract with anyone other than a residential occupier, Part II of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 sets the frame for when you are paid.

  • Stage payments. Under section 109 you are entitled to payment by instalments, stages or other periodic payments unless the contract says the work will last less than 45 days, or the parties agree it is estimated to. The amounts and intervals are yours to agree; if you agree none, the Scheme for Construction Contracts fills the gap.
  • A mechanism and a final date. Section 110 requires every construction contract to set out what payments become due and when, and a final date for payment for each sum. Making payment conditional on performance under another contract generally does not count.
  • No pay when paid. Section 113 makes a clause that conditions your payment on the payer being paid by somebody else ineffective, unless that somebody is insolvent.
  • Notices. The payer’s payment notice and any pay less notice have deadlines, and missing them can leave the payer owing the sum you applied for in full. See what is a pay less notice and applications for payment vs invoices.
  • Suspension. If the notified sum is not paid by the final date for payment, section 112 lets you suspend some or all of your work on at least seven days’ notice stating the grounds, and recover a reasonable amount for the costs of doing so.

For the forecast, the final date for payment is the date to plan around: after it, the money is late.

Free toolPayment date calculatorPut in an application date and get the due date, both notice deadlines and the final date for payment to drop into your forecast.

How do VAT and CIS change the timing?

VAT

On a job paid in one sum, VAT on construction services is due at the basic tax point, when the work is done, or on the invoice date if you invoice within 14 days of it. It goes on that quarter’s return whether or not the customer has paid. On contracts with stage or interim payments, the tax point is the earlier of receiving payment or issuing a VAT invoice, so a VAT invoice sent before you are paid brings the VAT forward, and an application that is not a VAT invoice does not. VAT on retention is not due until the retention is paid to you or invoiced.

The Cash Accounting Scheme turns that round: you pay VAT on a sale when the customer pays you. You can join if your estimated taxable turnover for the next twelve months is £1.35 million or less, and must leave above £1.6 million. It cannot be used with the Flat Rate Scheme, for reverse charge supplies, where a VAT invoice is raised in advance, or where the payment terms are six months or more. The registration side is in the VAT registration threshold for builders.

Returns and payments are usually due one calendar month and seven days after each quarter. Keep the VAT you collect apart from the money you run jobs on, because it is HMRC’s. If you cannot pay in full, HMRC may agree a payment plan, but it checks the plan is affordable and expects savings to be used first.

CIS

A subcontractor paid under CIS has 20% of the labour withheld if registered and verified, 30% if not, and nothing with gross payment status. The deductions are advance payments of tax. A sole trader recovers any overpayment only after the Self Assessment return; a limited company sets them against what it owes through its payroll submissions and can carry the excess forward within the same tax year. For a labour-heavy subcontractor on thin margins, that is money waiting on HMRC. Gross status ends the wait; see CIS gross payment status.

What are the warning signs?

  • Suppliers paid late to cover wages, or wages paid late to cover suppliers.
  • The quarter’s VAT spent before the return is due.
  • Applications going in after the date the contract sets, so a month’s payment slips by a month.
  • Variations done and not yet agreed, building up as cost with nothing coming in against them.
  • Retention with a release date that has passed and no request made for it.
  • One customer owing more than the business could absorb if it stopped paying.
  • Every job starting with a materials order and no deposit or first stage payment against it.
  • A cost value reconciliation showing profit while the bank balance falls month after month. See what is cost value reconciliation.
Free toolRetention calculatorWork out what is held on a job, what a cap does to it, and the two dates the money is due back, so retention goes into the forecast on its date.

How does Estimark help?

Estimark’s cash flow forecasting holds a forecast per job in dated monthly periods, each with forecast income and forecast cost, and a distribution you choose so the curve can follow the S most jobs take. You enter the figures: Estimark does not generate them from the estimate and has no bank feed. The forecast sits beside payment applications, which compute the due date, the payment notice deadline and the final date for payment from the application date, and a retention dashboard shows what is due back within 30 and 90 days. Invoice payment status comes back each day from Xero, QuickBooks or Sage Business Cloud.

The thirteen-week view above is weekly and covers the whole business, overheads included. Estimark’s forecast is monthly and per job, so the weekly view is still yours to build, from dates Estimark already holds. More on payment applications and retention.

Sources

Questions

Frequently asked

Why do profitable building firms run out of cash?

Because costs go out before payment comes in. Materials and labour are paid for weeks before the stage or application they belong to is paid, retention holds back part of each payment, and CIS deductions and VAT can take cash before the customer has paid. A profitable job can need several times its profit in working cash at its low point.

How far ahead should a builder forecast cash flow?

Thirteen weeks, by the week, rolled forward every week, is a practical horizon: it covers a VAT quarter and at least two valuation cycles. Longer-range forecasts by job and by month sit alongside it for planning.

Am I entitled to stage payments on a building contract?

On a construction contract covered by the Construction Act, yes, unless the work is to last less than 45 days: section 109 gives the right, and the Scheme for Construction Contracts supplies terms if the contract has none. On work for a homeowner in their own home the Act does not apply, so stage payments depend on what the quote and contract say.

Can a main contractor pay me only when it gets paid?

Not under a construction contract covered by the Act. Section 113 makes a pay when paid clause ineffective unless the party further up the chain is insolvent.

Does VAT cash accounting help a builder’s cash flow?

It can, because VAT on a sale is paid when the customer pays rather than when you invoice. It is open up to £1.35 million of estimated taxable turnover, but it cannot be used for reverse charge supplies or alongside the Flat Rate Scheme.

Does Estimark connect to my bank account?

No. The cash flow forecast in Estimark works from figures you enter per job per month, compared with the payment applications and job cost records already held, and invoice payment status comes back from your accounting package each day.

Build on a solid foundation.

Run the whole business without an implementation project and without legacy baggage. Every plan starts with 14 days free. No card needed.

Estimating · Jobs · Invoicing · CIS · H&S · Reactive maintenance