Construction Act

How does construction adjudication work?

13 min read

The short answer

Adjudication is a fast statutory route for resolving a dispute under a construction contract. Section 108 of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 gives every party to a construction contract the right to refer a dispute to an adjudicator at any time. The adjudicator should be appointed and the dispute referred within 7 days of the notice of adjudication, and the decision is due within 28 days of referral, extendable by 14 days with the referring party’s consent, or longer if both parties agree. The decision binds both sides until the dispute is finally determined by a court, arbitration or agreement, and the Technology and Construction Court enforces unpaid decisions quickly, usually by summary judgment. Where the contract has no compliant procedure, the Scheme for Construction Contracts supplies one. Contracts with a homeowner for work on their own home are excluded.

At a glance

Right to refer
At any time (HGCRA 1996 s.108)
Appointment and referral
Within 7 days of the notice
Decision
28 days from referral
Extensions
14 days with referring party’s consent, longer if both agree
Effect
Binding until finally determined
Fallback procedure
Scheme for Construction Contracts, Part I
Excluded
Contracts with a residential occupier (s.106)
Writing needed
No, since 1 Oct 2011 (E and W), 1 Nov 2011 (Scotland)

What is construction adjudication?

A statutory fast track for disputes under construction contracts. An independent adjudicator decides within weeks, and the decision binds both parties straight away, though either can later have the dispute finally decided by a court or an arbitrator. The right comes from section 108 of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, the Construction Act, and a dispute includes any difference.

A party to a construction contract has the right to refer a dispute arising under the contract for adjudication. Section 108(1), Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996.

Every construction contract must contain a procedure that:

  • lets a party give notice of its intention to refer a dispute at any time;
  • aims to secure the adjudicator’s appointment and the referral within 7 days of that notice;
  • requires a decision within 28 days of referral, or longer if both parties agree after the referral;
  • lets the adjudicator extend that by up to 14 days with the consent of the referring party;
  • requires the adjudicator to act impartially, and lets them take the initiative in ascertaining the facts and the law;
  • makes the decision binding until the dispute is finally determined by legal proceedings, arbitration or agreement.

If the contract’s procedure falls short of any of those, the adjudication provisions of the Scheme for Construction Contracts apply instead (section 108(5)). In England and Wales that is Part I of the Schedule to the Scheme for Construction Contracts (England and Wales) Regulations 1998.

Which contracts carry the right to adjudicate?

Most construction work between businesses. Under sections 104 and 105, a construction contract is one for carrying out construction operations, arranging for others to carry them out, or providing labour for them, including architectural, design and surveying work. Construction operations include building, alteration, repair, maintenance, extension and demolition, installing heating, lighting, drainage and similar systems, decorating, and preparatory work such as site clearance, excavation and scaffolding.

Section 105(2) excludes some operations, among them drilling for oil or gas, mineral extraction, and the manufacture or delivery to site of components and materials unless the contract also covers installing them. The Act covers operations in England, Wales and Scotland.

Homeowners are excluded. Section 106 takes out a construction contract with a residential occupier: one that principally relates to operations on a dwelling which one of the parties occupies, or intends to occupy, as their residence. A homeowner’s kitchen extension is outside the Act. A landlord’s refurbishment of a house it lets is inside it, because the landlord does not live there.

NoteYou can still write adjudication into a contract with a homeowner. It is then a contractual right, not a statutory one, and as a term of a consumer contract it must pass the fairness test in section 62 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015. See is a builder’s quote legally binding?

Verbal contracts are covered. The Act once applied only to contracts in writing. The Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Act 2009 repealed that requirement for contracts entered into on or after 1 October 2011 in England and Wales and 1 November 2011 in Scotland. A contract agreed on the phone is a construction contract, and where it says nothing in writing about adjudication, the Scheme supplies the procedure.

How does an adjudication run, step by step?

The Scheme’s procedure in England and Wales, which applies whenever the contract’s own does not comply.

  1. 01Put the claim in writing first. The right is to refer a dispute, so set out what you are owed or what you say is wrong, with the basis, and give the other side the chance to answer.
  2. 02Serve the notice of adjudication on every other party to the contract. It must set out briefly the nature of the dispute and the parties, where and when it arose, the redress you want, and the parties’ names and addresses (paragraph 1).
  3. 03Secure an adjudicator. Ask the person named in the contract; failing that, the nominating body the contract names; failing that, any adjudicator nominating body. Send a copy of the notice with the request (paragraphs 2 and 3). A nominating body must name an adjudicator within 5 days, and the person asked must say within 2 days whether they will act. The adjudicator must be an individual, not an employee of either party, and must declare any interest (paragraph 4).
  4. 04Serve the referral notice on the adjudicator not later than 7 days from the date of the notice of adjudication, with the contract or relevant extracts and the documents you rely on, and send copies to every other party at the same time (paragraph 7).
  5. 05The adjudicator runs the procedure. They set the timetable, can ask for documents, meet the parties, visit the site and, after telling the parties, appoint experts (paragraph 13). A party that ignores directions risks the adjudicator carrying on without it and drawing inferences (paragraph 15).
  6. 06The decision is due within 28 days of the adjudicator receiving the referral notice, 42 days if the referring party consents, or longer if both parties agree (paragraph 19). Reasons are given if a party asks (paragraph 22).
  7. 07Comply. Unless the adjudicator directs otherwise, the parties must comply immediately on delivery of the decision (paragraph 21).
StepTime limitSource
Notice of adjudicationAt any times.108(2)(a); Scheme para 1
Adjudicator says whether they will act2 days from the requestScheme paras 2(2), 5(3), 6(2)
Nominating body names an adjudicator5 days from the requestScheme para 5(1)
Referral noticeNot later than 7 days from the noticeScheme para 7(1)
Decision28 days from receipt of the referralScheme para 19(1)(a)
Extended decision42 days with referring party’s consent, or as both agreeScheme para 19(1)(b) and (c)
Correcting a slip5 days from delivery of the decisionScheme para 22A(2)

The Scheme for Construction Contracts (England and Wales) Regulations 1998, Part I, as amended in 2011.

NoteOne dispute, one decision. An adjudicator must resign where the dispute is the same or substantially the same as one already decided in an earlier adjudication (paragraph 9(2)), so put the whole of a claim into the referral.

What does adjudication cost, and who pays?

There are two kinds of cost, and the rules treat them differently.

  • The adjudicator’s fees and expenses. Under paragraph 25 of the Scheme, the adjudicator is entitled to a reasonable amount for fees and expenses reasonably incurred and decides how it is split between the parties, and the parties are jointly and severally liable for anything left unpaid. Ask for the adjudicator’s rates before the appointment is confirmed.
  • Each side’s own costs. Lawyers, claims consultants, experts and your own time. The Scheme gives the adjudicator power over their own fees, not the parties’ costs. Section 108A, added by the 2009 Act, makes a contract term allocating adjudication costs ineffective unless it is in the written contract and only lets the adjudicator allocate their own fees and expenses, or it is agreed in writing after the notice of adjudication. So each side normally bears its own costs, unless both agree otherwise once the dispute has started.

Weigh both against the sum in dispute before serving a notice. A dispute decided on notices and dates needs far less evidence than one about the value of work, delay or defects.

What is a smash and grab adjudication?

An adjudication about the payment notices rather than the value of the work. It rests on three sections of the Act.

  • Section 110A. The payer must give a payment notice not later than five days after the payment due date, stating the sum it considers due and the basis on which it is calculated, even if that sum is zero.
  • Section 110B. If the payer gives no payment notice, the payee’s own notice stands. Where the contract lets the payee apply before the payer’s notice is due, the application counts as that notice.
  • Section 111. The payer must pay the notified sum by the final date for payment, unless it gives a pay less notice, stating the sum it considers due and the basis, not later than the agreed period before the final date, or seven days under the Scheme.

When the payer serves neither notice in time, the payee refers the unpaid notified sum to adjudication. The adjudicator is not asked what the work was worth, only whether valid notices were served in time, so the issues are narrow and the evidence is mostly dates. The notices themselves are explained in what is a pay less notice? and applications for payment vs invoices.

The payer can then start a second, true value adjudication to have the work valued. In Grove Developments Ltd v S&T (UK) Ltd [2018] EWCA Civ 2448, the Court of Appeal held that the employer must first pay the notified sum, as section 111 requires, before it can begin a true value adjudication.

Pay the notified sum first, argue about value second. The payment obligation in section 111 comes before any adjudication of what the work was worth.

An unpaid notified sum also gives the payee a right to suspend performance on at least seven days’ notice stating the grounds, with a reasonable amount for the costs of suspending and the lost time disregarded (section 112).

Free toolPayment date calculatorDue date, both notice deadlines and the final date for payment from one application date, so you know whether a notice was late before you refer it.

What happens if the losing side does not pay?

The decision is binding and must be complied with until the dispute is finally determined by legal proceedings, arbitration or agreement (section 108(3) and paragraph 23(2) of the Scheme). If the losing party does not pay, the winner enforces the decision in the Technology and Construction Court, which the TCC Guide says has moulded a rapid procedure because the adjudication itself takes 28 days.

  1. 01Issue a claim, usually under CPR Part 7, with an application for summary judgment under CPR Part 24 and for shortened time limits, supported by a witness statement exhibiting the notice of adjudication and the decision.
  2. 02A TCC judge ordinarily gives directions on the papers within 3 working days of receiving the application.
  3. 03The hearing is ordinarily fixed within about 6 to 8 weeks of the directions, with the defendant given at least 14 days from service to serve any evidence in opposition.
  4. 04Claims for less than £100,000 should ordinarily be started in the County Court.

The grounds for resisting enforcement are limited. Where proceedings overlap, the court first considers any jurisdictional or natural justice defences, and a challenge to an adjudicator who acted within their jurisdiction but made a clear error on the merits is appropriate only exceptionally, by a separate Part 8 claim (TCC Guide, paragraphs 10.4.2.2 and 10.4.2.6).

An adjudicator’s decision binds until the dispute is finally determined. Comply first, then take the merits to court, arbitration or agreement.

What records win an adjudication?

The ones that already exist. The referral notice goes in with the documents you rely on, and 28 days leaves no time to reconstruct a year of a job from memory.

  • The contract or, for a verbal one, the emails and messages that show its terms.
  • Every application, payment notice and pay less notice, with the date each was sent and how.
  • Instructions and variations, numbered, with who gave them and when.
  • A daily site record of weather, labour and plant on site, work done, delays and visitors. See how to keep a site diary that holds up in a dispute.
  • Delay notices and extension of time claims, with the programme they rely on. See extension of time.
  • Dated photographs tied to a location on the job.

Is adjudication different in Scotland and Northern Ireland?

Scotland. Part II of the Act applies, with its own Scheme, the Scheme for Construction Contracts (Scotland) Regulations 1998. Its timetable follows the same pattern, though its 28 days run from the date of the referral notice rather than its receipt. The 2009 Act’s changes took effect there on 1 November 2011.

Northern Ireland. The Act does not apply. The Construction Contracts (Northern Ireland) Order 1997 gives the same right to adjudicate in Article 7, with the same 7-day, 28-day and 14-day periods and the same residential occupier exclusion, and the Scheme for Construction Contracts in Northern Ireland Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1999 fill any gaps.

Wales. Wales uses the England and Wales Scheme, amended by separate 2011 Welsh regulations that made parallel changes to the English ones.

How does Estimark help before a dispute?

Estimark does not run adjudications, serve notices or give legal advice. It holds the record an adjudication is argued from.

Payment applications carry the Construction Act dates computed from the application date: the due date, the payment notice deadline, the final date for payment and the pay less deadline. A pay less notice is recorded with its amount, its reason and the date it was served, and cannot be back-dated. One served after the deadline is refused, with a message naming the deadline and stating that the notified sum remains payable in full. The periods are defaults that cannot yet be set per contract, so check them against the payment clause you signed. See payment applications and retention in Estimark.

The site diary holds one dated entry per job per day with its author: weather and temperature, workers and plant on site, work carried out, delays in a field of their own, visitors and notes, with site photos linked to the day they show.

Sources

Questions

Frequently asked

How long does construction adjudication take?

The adjudicator should be appointed and the dispute referred within 7 days of the notice of adjudication, and the decision is due 28 days after referral. That can be extended to 42 days with the referring party’s consent, or longer if both parties agree.

Can a builder adjudicate against a homeowner?

Not under the Construction Act where the homeowner lives, or intends to live, in the property: section 106 excludes contracts with a residential occupier. The contract can give a right to adjudicate expressly, but as a term of a consumer contract it must be fair under section 62 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

Who pays for an adjudication?

The adjudicator decides how their own fees and expenses are split, and both parties are jointly and severally liable for any unpaid balance. Each side normally bears its own legal and expert costs, because section 108A makes a costs-shifting term ineffective unless it is agreed in writing after the notice of adjudication or only lets the adjudicator allocate their own fees.

Is an adjudicator’s decision final?

It is binding until the dispute is finally determined by legal proceedings, arbitration or agreement, and the parties must comply with it in the meantime. The parties can also agree to accept it as the final answer (section 108(3)).

Can a contract stop me adjudicating until the job is finished?

No. Section 108 requires the contract to let a party give notice at any time. A procedure that does not comply is replaced by the adjudication provisions of the Scheme for Construction Contracts (section 108(5)).

Do I need a lawyer for adjudication?

No. Under paragraph 16 of the Scheme a party may be assisted or represented by anyone it chooses, legally qualified or not, though only one person may represent it at an oral hearing unless the adjudicator directs otherwise.

Build on a solid foundation.

Run the whole business without an implementation project and without legacy baggage. Every plan starts with 14 days free. No card needed.

Estimating · Jobs · Invoicing · CIS · H&S · Reactive maintenance